Section Head Reviews

From U of M Internal Medicine Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Policy: Section Head Reviews
Policy Nr: Sec 02 - 06
Target Review Date: 2020-08-28
Main Stakeholder: Department Head


To ensure achievement and maintenance of academic, clinical, professional and leadership excellence through a transparent and fair process.


See Section Head Review Committee


The committee shall review the previous term's activities of the Section Head in relation to the following criteria:

  • Education (undergraduate, graduate and continuing)
  • Research – in evaluating research information pertaining to peer review grants, publications, participation in review panels
  • Professional Excellence – profile of the section within the department
  • Overall Clinical Effectiveness

The committee shall:

  • evaluate the leadership and organizational qualities of the Section Head as related to the function of the section
  • assess the contribution of the Section Head in relation to the wider activities of the department
  • identify, where relevant, how the section may have been prevented from achieving its goals
  • examine the goals and objectives of the section for the next five (5) years.

Review Committee Recommendations

The committee shall report its recommendations to the Department Head and may recommend the following options:

  1. renew for an additional two to five (2-5) year period with specific recommendations
  2. no renewal

Where possible, a Section Head’s review should be completed within three (3) months of the anniversary of their appointment, or last year review.

Committee Procedures

  1. The chair will not have a vote.
  2. The chair may disband the committee if it is unable to reach a satisfactory conclusion, or if confidentiality is breached.
  3. The Department Head will ensure that a consistent set of procedures is followed by the committee.
  4. While we cannot expect 100% attendance at all meetings, efforts should be made by committee members to be on time and attend the entire meeting.

Formats of Reviews

The Department Head will establish a timetable of upcoming reviews one (1) year in advance and remind each Section Head at least six (6) months in advance of the date.

Section Head Report

A section report will be prepared by the Section Head.

The report should include an assessment of the section’s progress in achieving previously stated objectives and a summary of section research, teaching and professional activities. This report will be sent to the committee members at least two (2) weeks prior to their meeting.

External Review

If External Reviews have been requested, the section report will be sent to the external reviewer(s) at least two (2) weeks prior to their arrival.

Faculty Member's Input

Opportunities will be made available for the committee to receive presentations from members of the section under review and other section heads or department members that may wish to come before the committee. Information may be sought from the Postgraduate Medical Education Committee and Undergraduate Medical Education Committee chairs, and any other people deemed appropriate by the committee Chair. The committee will discuss the submitted reports from the Section Head and when appropriate, the External Reviewer(s) report, prior to proceeding with the interviews.

Section Head Presentation

The committee will meet with the Section Head after which a final discussion will take place. The Section Head should be prepared to give a twenty (20) minute presentation outlining, briefly, past and present issues relevant to the review. The incumbent should also be prepared to indicate the future priorities and opportunities that should be pursued. A round table question period should follow.

Final Report

The decision of the review will be by consensus. If the chair of the committee is someone other than the Department Head, he/she will report to the Department Head the same day following each meeting to go over the findings and recommendations of the committee.

The report of the committee will be completed within two (2) weeks of its final meeting and copies of this report will be sent to the Department Head, who will subsequently notify university and hospital authorities with respect to the outcome of the review.

Related articles

Related articles: